NFU calls for delay to farm support changes after Agriculture Bill falls

Minette Batters - membership renewal - web crop_57050

This article was first published on 10 September after the government’s decision not to carry forward the current version of the Agriculture Bill into the next session of Parliament.

The NFU is calling for the government to delay its planned phasing out of farm support payments.

Farm support payments were due to be phased out from 2021 but NFU President Minette Batters has said it is ‘unreasonable’ to continue to plan for the phasing out of the current system on the present timetable.

Mrs Batters said: “With the fall of the Agriculture Bill, there is no guarantee at all that the legislation will be in place to enable the government to begin its planned transition to a new farm support system in 2021.

“It is totally unreasonable to keep farmers in a state of uncertainty about what system might be in place from 2021. We are proposing the government’s plans to move away from the current system are postponed by at least a year, to run from 2022 to 2028. We hope that continued uncertainty will not require a postponement of more than a year.

“The proposed new system was based on the UK leaving the EU in an orderly fashion in March 2019, entering a stable transition period for at least two years. That is obviously now a distant memory. There is every chance we could find ourselves leaving without a deal, facing huge economic disruption with farms struggling to remain viable. That is not the time to start dismantling the support system that has provides such important stability for many farm businesses.

“We have worked closely with Defra and other stakeholders across the environmental and farming sectors over the last two years to ensure the Agriculture Bill was fit for purpose. It is hugely disappointing that we now find ourselves in a position where a delay is necessary.

"We remain committed to working with our partners to develop a new system that will underpin a sustainable farming system in the UK for decades to come, but this cannot reasonably be done when so much of government’s time and resource is focused on managing the Brexit process and the potential impact of no deal.

“If we are to make a success of farming in the UK after Brexit, then its critical we get it right. Farmers will need to trust that the new system works properly, delivers its intended outcomes and rewards farmers both as producers of high-quality food and custodians of our farmed environment. Rushing the reform programme in the absence of any legal framework and with the outcome of Brexit still so uncertain could fatally undermine this hugely important piece of work.

“Farming is a long-term industry and businesses need sufficient time to prepare for such significant policy shift, not least to manage cash flow and the overall change this would bring to business.”

  • The government has failed to present a motion to MPs to carry over the existing bill, meaning that a new version of the bill will now need to be reintroduced in the next Queen’s Speech and begin its legislative passage right back at the beginning of the process. All the while uncertainty for farmers continues and the clock continues to tick down to 2021 when the government has said it will begin cutting farm payments and introduce a new system of support.
  • A recent National Audit Office report reinforced the NFU’s concerns. It highlighted serious concerns over the pace of the Defra programme regarding developing future farming support, and that sensible precautions, information systems and planning would not be in place in time. The NFU now has substantial doubts that these preparations can be done in time.

Read also:

NFU members: Have your say

Want to share your views? You must be logged in to comment – please login here. Not a member? Join us here.

  • Posted by: John MetcalfePosted on: 12/09/2019 20:43:30

    Comment: Now that the Agriculture Bill has failed to make progress the existing legislation governing Agriculture will remain in place until new legislation is passed into Law by the Government.
    This means that as an industry we are bound by the existing EU regulations even after we leave the EU until a new Act of Parliament which will be at least 2 years into the future.
    Surely this means that the Government cannot now reduce support payments without another Act of Parliament since the Agriculture Bill [now lost] was the only piece of legislation related to the revision of future support payments. Presumably this also means that as an industry we will not leave the EU rules on all other Agriculture related issues either?
    Please clarify our situation , as a Hill Farmer I am planning ahead for next year based on a series of assumptions which the Government have just scrapped !!!!
  • Posted by: NFU web teamPosted on: 13/09/2019 10:08:26

    Comment: Thanks for your comment John and your questions. An NFU adviser will be in touch.

  • © 2020 - NFUonline