BPS blog: The intermittent geyser

Guy Smith_27779

NFU Vice President Guy Smith crunches the numbers to try and work out who will get their BPS payment when.


He writes:

So 50 days have passed since the opening of the BPS window on December 1. And that means for many of us that for 50 mornings now we’ve woken up wondering if today is the day when we will be paid.

As I write (on 20/01/16), the RPA has just announced a new batch of payments  – 11,300 claimants have been sent a useful  £320 million. After some smaller releases around Christmas and the New Year, this is by far the most significant payment release since the 27,000 paid in the opening days of December. It’s as if the RPA are modelling themselves on some sort of unpredictable geyser - intermittently erupting and showering money down of randomly chosen sections of the rural economy. Sometimes it’s a disappointing little spurt and sometimes it is more impressive.

So let us do the maths again.

To date the RPA has paid out £780 million to 57,000 of the 87,000 total claimants. That leaves another 30,000 to be paid £700 million. Of those 30,000, we know 13,000 have received letters telling them they ‘are unlikely to be paid by the end of January’. Logically you can deduce from this that there are 17,000 claimants who can expect to be paid between now and the end of January. Those being the 17,000 who have had neither a letter nor payment.

More of our staff blogs...

Given we have become a little sceptical as to how ‘on top’ of making payments the RPA actually is, we can but live in hope that this will be achieved over the next ten to 15 days. Again we will stand around the geyser hole and hope it starts to erupt.

Of most concern are the 13,000 in the ‘letter of doom’ camp. These are people who have been inspected or have commons or have cross border claims or are classed as ‘super-complex’. To add to this confusion there are thousands of people who will have been inspected remotely so they are not aware of it. Our intuition tells us there have been IT problems with such claims which are only being sorted out now. You have to ask some fundamental questions as to why this wasn’t sorted beforehand. As to when these 13,000 will be paid – you can only hope it’s not long after February 1st and before Easter.

Obviously the NFU’s first demand and concern is to get money owing paid out to farmers as soon as possible whether it is for BPS or ELS/HLS. But, talking to our members, it is also becoming very clear that what is adding to the anxiety here is the fog of confusion as to when farmers will receive this money. We call on Defra, the RPA and Natural England to recognise that it is impossible to run a business when you don't know when you are likely to be paid.

Many farmers are now wondering when they will receive both their BPS payment and their second 50% HLS/ELS payment. Defra and its agencies must be more transparent and clear as to when they think this money will go out rather than hiding behind a veil of confusion.

It is worth noting that by March 10 it will be 100 days since the opening of the BPS payment window. The historians amongst you will remember that it took Napoleon just one hundred days to escape from his island prison of Elba, raise an army of 100,000, fight one of the most important battles in European history at Waterloo and be exiled to St.Helena in the South Atlantic.

So, you would have thought it was enough time for the RPA to pay out all the BPS.   


Last edited on: 20:01:2016

Share this story:

NFU members: Have your say

Want to share your views? You must be logged in to comment – please login here. Not a member? Join us here.

  • Posted by: Caroline BrooksPosted on: 20/01/2016 17:46:22

    Comment: I am having to borrow money from the bank until BPS is paid, so in effect the government is borrowing money from me without paying interest.
  • Posted by: Alastair WarringtonPosted on: 20/01/2016 17:48:10

    Comment: Well done Guy, or should I call you Mr Vice Chairman. You always did write a good line ! I must immediately check my bank to see if we are one of the lucky ones. The Inland Revenue have a vested interest in us being paid.
  • Posted by: Julian TaylorPosted on: 20/01/2016 18:27:54

    Comment: Like many Norfolk farmers attending the Norfolk Farming Conference,last autumn, (excellently chaired by Guy Smith), we heard Liz Truss reassuringly tell us all that there were no problems with BPS and the RPA. We now know this not to be true and that we are unable to construct our cash flows accurately for the end of this financial year, let alone give our bank believable figures for next year.
    I have not received the farm's BPS payment as yet and have had no indication when this overdue payment will be forthcoming. The whole system appears to be far too complex for our civil servants to administer, therefore please can the NFU apply real pressure on those at the top to simplify the whole regime.
    I am deeply concerned that should the Great British public decide that we are better out of Europe we seemingly have no plans in place to either financially support or not, this all important industry that not only feeds but also enhances the environment that is our wonderful countryside.
  • Posted by: S.R.SpencerPosted on: 20/01/2016 20:46:43

    Comment: In the harsh reality of the business world , late payments incur interest . ???
  • Posted by: Caroline HoskenPosted on: 22/01/2016 14:32:46

    Comment: We have had another "letter of doom" this morning saying we will NOT be paid by the end of January. Their reason is given as "BPS is a new scheme and applications need more checks on them this year because of the new scheme rules(for example, the new "greening" and "active farmer" rules)." none of which apply to our claim!! I am expecting interest to be paid on the money we are owed (not)!
  • Posted by: Bridget MaplethorpePosted on: 22/01/2016 14:37:50

    Comment: We have not received a letter (hooray!) We have not received any payment(Boo!) We cannot get any information about our claim from the RPA (Boo!) The pantomine continues...
  • Posted by: Chris HemmingPosted on: 06/02/2016 14:26:10

    Comment: As one of the 17,000 farmers not responded to in January and a new farmer, I have just received my letter of apology (Feb 6th)
    but have had to get a non farming job to meet my bills ....

  • © 2019 - NFU Online