Farmers Weekly: Farmers need to challenge 'anti-meat' reporting by the BBC

Minette Batters laptop web crop_66768

In a column for Farmers Weekly, NFU President Minette Batters breaks down the IPCC report and the 'anti-meat' agenda seen across media coverage.

Since the IPCC report made the headlines last week there has been plenty of discussion about how these topics are reported, especially within the BBC. The NFU has been in contact with the BBC multiple times over the past year and even met with senior BBC Directors to discuss the need for a more balanced and consistent representation of UK farming, especially when it comes to climate change. So as you can imagine I was incredibly frustrated to see the BBC’s headline “A plant based diet can fight climate change”.  I was frustrated because the report never said that… not once. 

Despite the headlines, the report was far from recommending we all adopt a vegetarian diet. In fact it actually acknowledged that sustainable livestock production is part of the climate solution, saying that “Balanced diets featuring plant-based foods and animal-sourced food produced sustainably in low greenhouse gas emission systems, present major opportunities for adaptation to and limiting climate change.” In the press conference, the report authors emphatically stated that they weren’t giving advice about peoples’ diets and that people should not focus on specific sectors as there is no silver bullet, and critically said “We’re not talking about giving up meat in this report at all”.

Nowhere did the report recommend going vegan or vegetarian. The report authors did however list numerous other ways to help the planet – including cutting waste and having a whole food chain approach from farm to fridge. None of that was reported.

We all know that British farmers are leading the way in climate-friendly food. We know that we work incredibly hard to be the best, whether it’s in terms of food safety, animal welfare or environmental protection, so of course it jars with us when the media takes these global reports and comes to a conclusion without understanding the domestic picture.

That’s where we have a role to play. As a community we have a responsibility to get our story out to the public who may not know that we have some of the most sustainable farming systems in the world, or that we have an ambition for net zero agriculture by 2040.

Over the course of the day myself, NFU Vice President Stuart Roberts and various NFU board chairmen covered the media to get out these messages to the public and turn the conversation back around to climate-friendly food production in Britain. We were on BBC News at 10, BBC News Channel, ITV Teatime News, Channel 4 News, a host of national BBC radio channels including the Today programme, Farming Today, Radio 1, 5 Live and World Service, and regional radio stations across the country. Like many of you, we were also on social media correcting the widespread misreporting of the report.

It is so frustrating that farming family businesses who are working hard to produce quality, sustainable, traceable and healthy British food feel under attack by our own broadcasters. I have never asked, nor expected, the BBC to be a PR machine for farming. And it is right that as farmers we are challenged. But the reporting of the IPCC report could never be described as a fair challenge. 

If we feel that the media is biased or misrepresenting the facts, we all have a responsibility to hold them to account. As members of the British public we have a right to be fairly represented in the media, and as BBC licence fee payers we have a right for our concerns to be listened to.

The NFU is writing a letter of complaint. And if you have the same concerns as I do – let them know it. In this age of ‘fake’ news we all need to stand up and set the record straight. 




© 2020 - NFUonline