Blog: The NFU's High Court battle with Friends of the Earth

cabbage stem flea beetle damage

lucy smith, legal adviser, nfu staff_275_412The NFU was in Court last week fighting Friends of the Earth over the emergency authorisations of two neonicotinoid seed treatments. Legal adviser Lucy Smith takes up the story…

She writes:

More of our staff blogs...

Chris Hartfield_275_413NFU horticulture expert Chris Hartfield - Waste Not Campaign puts spotlight on retailers and the public

Sian Davies_200_299Chief dairy adviser Sian Davies - What's the story on Milk for Farmers?

Ruth Mason_170_255Chief food chain adviser Ruth Mason - Are retailers listening to customers on British food?

Anna Logan_170_251BPS adviser Anna Logan: The top four mistakes to avoid on common land claims

Richard Bramley_275_183Richard Bramley, NFU Environment Forum member -Helping farmland birds while running a productive business

Richard Wordsworth_275_412Senior BPS adviser Richard Wordsworth - When will I receive my BPS payment?

Richard Bramley_275_183Richard Bramley, NFU Environment Forum member - Can't pay? Won't pay? Then who pays?

Sian Davies_200_299NFU chief dairy advierSian Davies - Government urged to show leadership and back British dairy

Diane Mitchell_200_298NFU chief environment adviser Diane Mitchell - CAP must strike right balance on food and the environment

The NFU was in Court last week fighting Friends of the Earth over the emergency authorisations of two neonicotinoid seed treatments. Farmers can now breathe a welcome sigh of relief as the Judge has ruled that Friends of the Earth’s legal challenge is “unarguable”.

The environmental campaign group attempted to bring a legal challenge against the Government’s decision to grant the temporary authorisations. However, the NFU believes it is crucial for members to have access to these much-needed plant protection products. We know that oilseed rape growers in the East and South East of England have suffered exceptional and devastating yield losses due to pressure from Cabbage Stem Flea Beetle and so we were determined to fight the case on behalf of our members.

The NFU was an interested party in the case because we had applied for the authorisations, and we have been working tirelessly over the last few months to ensure that our members’ interests were represented to the Court. We have made excellent use of the NFU’s in-house expertise, with our Legal, Horticulture, Crops and Regulatory teams all working together to put forward the best possible case for farmers.

Last Thursday, we travelled to London for a hearing at the Royal Courts of Justice to determine whether or not Friends of the Earth’s challenge should be allowed to proceed. It was an exciting and rather tense day, but fortunately some light relief was on hand in the form of two campaigners in bee costumes!

We are delighted with the judge’s ruling and we hope that our members are too. We’ll keep at it; working to ensure that farmers have access to the critical plant protection products that they need.

More from the Legal team: