“Experience matters”, says NFU Poultry Board member on new training route

NFU Poultry Board member Matthew Donald explains how member feedback and NFU lobbying helped secure the new Assessment First Route under the Poultry Passport scheme.

Poultry farmers know that completing a qualification is not the only way someone becomes skilled at their job.

Many people working on farms have built up years, sometimes decades, of practical experience and demonstrate high standards of bird welfare, health and safety and stockmanship every day.

That is why, based on feedback from members, the NFU has consistently argued that the poultry training system must recognise existing knowledge and experience.

Experience should count

Under the Poultry Passport scheme, staff working in Level 2 roles, such as stockpersons and multi-skilled operatives, and Level 3 roles, including assistant managers and managers, are required to hold the City & Guilds Diploma in Work-Based Agriculture (Poultry Production) or an equivalent qualification.

For some experienced poultry workers, being required to complete every training module before taking an assessment felt over burdensome. They already possess the skills and knowledge being taught and completing the full programme would take them away from the farm and bring additional costs to the business.

Some NFU members understandably wanted experienced workers to be exempt through what are often called grandfather rights.

How the NFU responded

The NFU took those views directly into discussions with the management group for British Poultry Training, of which it is a member of, and pressed strongly for practical experience to be properly recognised.

The British Poultry Training management committee decided that a blanket exemption would not be offered. While this was not the outcome we had hoped for, the NFU continued negotiating rather than accepting a system that required every experienced worker to follow the same training route. Finding a solution was key.

The continued and lengthy discussions helped secure a workable compromise: the new Assessment First Route.

To read more about the workable compromise, visit: New assessment-only route to poultry certification – NFUonline

How the Assessment First Route works

The route allows poultry workers who already have the necessary knowledge and skills to go straight to the end assessment without completing the training modules first. If they demonstrate the required level of competence, they can achieve the same City & Guilds Diploma through an assessment-only process.

The route launched in July and for those in the next intake who were already enrolled but not started on the Diploma when the route became available, they were able to discuss with their training provider whether this new assessment option was appropriate for them.

This meant eligible workers did not have to go on to complete full training modules unnecessarily and if they were ready to demonstrate their competence through the final assessment they could opt-on to the new route.

The new route should reduce the time and cost involved in gaining certification, particularly for workers who have already spent many years caring for poultry and managing birds to a high standard.

Maintaining high standards

Importantly, this is not about lowering standards. Workers must still show that they meet the requirements of the qualification. It is about providing a fairer and more proportionate way for capable, experienced people to prove what they know.

If someone fails the end assessment because they haven’t got the necessary knowledge and expertise then they will have to go on to complete the full training modules as part of the Diploma and take the assessment again. This is chargeable by the training provider and will end up costing more so there’s no point trying to cheat the system!

Why member representation matters

I know the solution secured will not satisfy everyone. Some members will continue to feel that long-serving and demonstrably competent workers should have received a full exemption. That view was heard and represented clearly by the NFU throughout the discussions.

However, where an exemption could not be agreed, it was important that we secured another option. This is a good example of why strong member representation matters.

The NFU listened to the concerns raised by poultry businesses, challenged the original approach and stayed at the table to negotiate a more practical route.

It may not be a perfect solution, but it gives experienced workers a meaningful choice and ensures their knowledge counts and I encourage all businesses to look at both routes going forwards to see which is the most suitable for their workers. 

More from NFUonline:

This page was first published on 17 November 2026.


Ask us a question about this page

Once you have submitted your query someone from NFU CallFirst will contact you. If needed, your query will then be passed to the appropriate NFU policy team.

You have 0 characters remaining.

By completing the form with your details on this page, you are agreeing to have this information sent to the NFU for the purposes of contacting you regarding your enquiry. Please take time to read the NFU’s Privacy Notice if you require further information.

}